How to Write a Compare and Contrast Essay for High School

TL;DR

A compare and contrast essay examines how two subjects are similar and different. Choose subjects with enough in common to compare meaningfully. Use either block structure (all of Subject A, then all of Subject B) or point-by-point structure (alternating between A and B for each criterion). Include a thesis that makes an argument, not just "they're similar and different."

Why Teachers Love This Assignment

The compare and contrast essay is probably the most assigned essay in high school English. You've done it, your parents did it, and your grandparents probably did it too.

Why? Because comparing things is literally how humans make sense of the world. Every time you decide between two restaurants, debate which Marvel movie is better, or choose between studying for bio or finishing your English paper first — you're comparing and contrasting.

Your teachers assign these essays because they want you to think critically about relationships between ideas, not just describe stuff. And once you understand the formula, these essays practically write themselves.

Let's break it down.

Step 1: Understand What You're Really Being Asked

A compare and contrast essay does TWO things:

Compare = how the subjects are SIMILAR
Contrast = how the subjects are DIFFERENT

Seems obvious, right? But here's where students mess up: they think the whole point is just to list similarities and differences. It's not.

The actual point is to make an argument about WHY those similarities and differences matter.

Bad thesis: "Dogs and cats are similar in some ways and different in others." (No kidding. That's not an insight — that's a fact about literally any two things.)

Good thesis: "While both dogs and cats make rewarding pets, dogs are better suited for active families because they require more social interaction and physical exercise."

See the difference? The good thesis uses the comparison to make a POINT.

Step 2: Choose Your Subjects Wisely

If your teacher gives you the choice, pick subjects that are:

Similar Enough to Compare

You can't write a meaningful essay comparing a pencil to democracy. The subjects need to be in the same general category:

Two books by the same author
Two historical events
Two scientific theories
Two characters in the same novel
Two political systems

Different Enough to Contrast

If two things are basically the same, there's nothing interesting to say. Make sure there are genuine, meaningful differences.

Relevant to Each Other

The comparison should reveal something interesting. Ask yourself: "What do I learn by comparing these two things that I wouldn't learn by studying them separately?"

Great compare/contrast topics:

High school vs. college
Online school vs. in-person school
Two characters who make different choices
Two approaches to solving the same problem
Two historical figures who lived in different eras

Weak compare/contrast topics:

Pizza vs. the American Revolution (unrelated)
A rock vs. a slightly different rock (too similar)
Something you know nothing about vs. something else you know nothing about

Step 3: Brainstorm Your Points

Before you write anything, you need to identify your comparison criteria — the specific aspects you'll examine.

The Venn Diagram Method

You've been doing Venn diagrams since elementary school, and they're still useful:

Draw two overlapping circles
Label each circle with one subject
In the left section: unique qualities of Subject A
In the right section: unique qualities of Subject B
In the overlapping middle: shared qualities

The Chart Method (More Organized)

I actually prefer a comparison chart:

Criteria	Subject A	Subject B
Criteria 1	Detail	Detail
Criteria 2	Detail	Detail
Criteria 3	Detail	Detail
Criteria 4	Detail	Detail

Example: Comparing High School and College

Criteria	High School	College
Schedule	Fixed, 7-8 classes daily	Flexible, you choose when
Homework	Nightly, checked daily	Less frequent, larger assignments
Teacher involvement	Teachers track your progress	Professors expect independence
Social life	Mostly predetermined	You build your own community

Now you've got organized material to work with.

Choosing the Best Criteria

You don't need to compare EVERY possible aspect. Pick 3-4 criteria that:

Are genuinely significant (not trivial)
Reveal interesting similarities OR differences
Support the argument you want to make

Step 4: Choose Your Structure

This is the most important decision in a compare/contrast essay. There are two main structures:

Option A: Block Structure (Subject by Subject)

How it works: Discuss ALL aspects of Subject A first, then ALL aspects of Subject B.

Outline:

I. Introduction + Thesis II. Subject A

Criteria 1
Criteria 2
Criteria 3 III. Subject B
Criteria 1 (connect back to A)
Criteria 2 (connect back to A)
Criteria 3 (connect back to A) IV. Conclusion

Best for:

Shorter essays (2-3 pages)
When subjects are very different
When you want to give a complete picture of each subject

Danger: It can feel like two separate essays stapled together. You MUST connect Subject B back to Subject A with transitions like "Unlike Subject A..." or "Similarly to Subject A..."

Option B: Point-by-Point Structure (Criteria by Criteria)

How it works: For each criterion, discuss BOTH subjects before moving to the next criterion.

Outline:

I. Introduction + Thesis II. Criteria 1

Subject A
Subject B
Analysis III. Criteria 2
Subject A
Subject B
Analysis IV. Criteria 3
Subject A
Subject B
Analysis V. Conclusion

Best for:

Longer essays (4+ pages)
When you want to emphasize specific comparisons
When subjects are fairly similar and the differences are in the details

Advantage: The comparison is always front and center. The reader never has to flip back to remember what you said about Subject A.

Which One Should You Use?

General rule: Point-by-point is usually the safer choice for high school essays. It's harder for your essay to feel like two separate papers, and it shows stronger analytical thinking.

But if your teacher recommends block structure, go with that. Know your audience.

Step 5: Write a Strong Thesis Statement

Your thesis needs to do three things:

Identify the subjects being compared
Indicate whether you're focusing on similarities, differences, or both
Make an argument (a "so what?" statement)

Thesis Templates

Similarity focus: "Although [Subject A] and [Subject B] differ in [difference], they share [similarity 1], [similarity 2], and [similarity 3], suggesting that [argument]."

Difference focus: "While [Subject A] and [Subject B] both [similarity], they differ significantly in [criteria 1], [criteria 2], and [criteria 3], which reveals [argument]."

Both: "[Subject A] and [Subject B] share [similarities], but their key differences in [criteria] demonstrate that [argument]."

Examples

❌ "Romeo and Juliet and West Side Story have similarities and differences." (This says nothing. Every two things have similarities and differences.)

✅ "While Romeo and Juliet and West Side Story share the same tragic love story structure, West Side Story's modern setting and social commentary on racial tensions make it a more politically urgent adaptation."

❌ "Online school and in-person school are different." (Obviously.)

✅ "Although online schooling offers greater flexibility, in-person schooling provides the social interaction and structured accountability that most high school students need to succeed academically."

Step 6: Write the Body Paragraphs

Each body paragraph should follow this structure:

Topic Sentence

State the criterion being compared and hint at the comparison.

Example: "The scheduling flexibility in college represents one of the most dramatic changes from high school."

Subject A Discussion

Present evidence, details, and examples about Subject A for this criterion.

Example: "In high school, students follow a rigid schedule of 7-8 classes per day, arriving at 7:30 AM and leaving at 2:30 PM with minimal choice in when classes occur."

Subject B Discussion

Present evidence, details, and examples about Subject B for the same criterion. Use transition words to connect back to Subject A.

Example: "In contrast, college students often have gaps between classes, may have entire days without lectures, and can choose between morning and afternoon sections of the same course."

Analysis

Explain what this comparison reveals. Why does this similarity or difference matter?

Example: "This increased freedom, while appealing, requires significantly stronger time management skills — something many freshmen struggle to develop after years of externally structured schedules."

Transition Words You'll Need

For similarities: similarly, likewise, in the same way, both, equally, also, just as, like, comparable to

For differences: however, in contrast, on the other hand, whereas, unlike, while, although, conversely, despite, nevertheless

Don't start every paragraph with "Also" or "Another difference is." Vary your transitions.

Step 7: Write the Introduction and Conclusion

Introduction Formula

Hook: An interesting observation, question, or scenario related to your subjects
Context: Brief background on both subjects
Thesis: Your argument about the comparison

Example: "Every year, millions of students face the same question: should I take the SAT or the ACT? While both tests claim to measure college readiness, their structural differences in timing, content emphasis, and scoring mean that most students will naturally perform better on one than the other. Understanding these differences is the first step toward choosing the test that plays to your strengths."

Conclusion Formula

Restate your thesis (in different words)
Summarize key points (briefly — don't re-argue everything)
"So what?" statement: Why does this comparison matter? What should the reader take away?

Don't introduce new information in the conclusion. And PLEASE don't start with "In conclusion," — your teacher will silently judge you.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

1. The "List" Essay

Just listing similarities and differences without analyzing why they matter. Remember: you need an argument, not just observations.

2. Unbalanced Coverage

Spending three paragraphs on Subject A and one paragraph on Subject B. Give them roughly equal attention.

3. Forced Comparisons

If you're stretching to find a similarity or difference, it probably isn't worth including. Only use criteria that yield genuine, meaningful insights.

4. No Transitions

Jumping between subjects without connecting them. Every time you switch from A to B, use a transition word or phrase.

5. Describing Instead of Analyzing

"Subject A is red. Subject B is blue." That's description. "Subject A's red color symbolizes passion, while Subject B's blue reflects calm, revealing the contrasting emotional tones of each work" — THAT's analysis.

6. Choosing Incomparable Subjects

If you're choosing your own subjects, make sure there's a logical reason to compare them. "Both are books" isn't enough of a connection.

Sample Outline: Online vs. In-Person Learning

Here's a complete point-by-point outline to model:

Thesis: "While online learning offers unmatched flexibility and accessibility, in-person learning provides the social interaction and structured accountability that most high school students need for academic success."

I. Introduction

Hook: COVID shifted education forever
Context: Both modes are now common options
Thesis

II. Body 1: Schedule and Flexibility

Online: Self-paced, study when you want
In-person: Fixed schedule, less flexibility
Analysis: Flexibility is great IF you have discipline

III. Body 2: Social Interaction

Online: Limited peer interaction, Zoom fatigue
In-person: Daily face-to-face contact, collaboration
Analysis: Social skills and connections matter for development

IV. Body 3: Accountability and Support

Online: Self-motivated, easy to fall behind
In-person: Teachers notice when you're struggling
Analysis: Most HS students need external structure

V. Conclusion

Restate thesis
Both have value depending on the student
The future is probably a hybrid approach

How Gradily Can Help

Stuck brainstorming your comparison criteria? Not sure if your thesis actually makes an argument? Gradily can help you:

Brainstorm meaningful comparison points
Strengthen your thesis statement
Outline your essay in either structure
Review your draft for logical flow and analysis depth

It's like having a writing tutor available whenever you need one.

Final Thoughts

The compare and contrast essay isn't just a school assignment — it's a thinking skill you'll use for the rest of your life. Every major decision involves weighing options, identifying tradeoffs, and making judgments.

Pick the right structure, write a thesis that makes an argument, use strong transitions, and analyze (don't just describe).

You've compared a million things in your life. Now you're just doing it on paper. You've got this.

Editorial Standards