How to Get an A in College Writing (Composition 101)

TL;DR

• College writing is about analysis and argument, not the five-paragraph essay from high school
• Professors care most about thesis clarity, evidence integration, and critical thinking
• The biggest freshman mistake is summarizing instead of analyzing
• Go to your professor's office hours — they'll tell you exactly what they want
• Revision is where the magic happens — first drafts aren't supposed to be good
• Read the assignment rubric carefully — it literally tells you how to get an A

---

The Reality of College Writing Classes

Composition 101 (or whatever your school calls it) is often a rude awakening. You walked in thinking you were a decent writer — maybe you got A's on your high school essays — and then your first college paper comes back with a C+ and comments like "needs deeper analysis" and "thesis is too vague."

What happened? You didn't suddenly become a worse writer. You entered a system with different expectations.

High school writing rewards:

• Following the five-paragraph structure
• Having a clear opinion
• Correctly using grammar and spelling
• Meeting the page count
• Writing in complete sentences (the bar is low)

College writing rewards:

• Making complex, nuanced arguments
• Supporting claims with textual evidence and analysis
• Engaging with counterarguments
• Developing original ideas
• Demonstrating critical thinking
• Writing with sophistication and clarity

The gap between these two sets of expectations is where most freshmen struggle. Let's close that gap.

---

What Professors Actually Want

1. A Clear, Arguable Thesis

Your thesis statement is the most important sentence in your paper. It needs to be:

Specific: Not "Social media is bad" but "The algorithmic amplification of sensational content on social media platforms has eroded the quality of public political discourse by prioritizing emotional reactions over factual accuracy."

Arguable: Someone should be able to disagree with your thesis. If it's a statement of fact ("The Civil War happened in the 1860s"), it's not a thesis.

Analytical: Your thesis should reveal something about your topic that isn't immediately obvious. It should make your reader think.

Bad thesis: "In this essay, I will discuss the effects of social media on teenagers." Better thesis: "While social media platforms market themselves as tools for connection, their design incentivizes performative self-presentation that increases anxiety and loneliness among teenage users."

2. Evidence That's Actually Analyzed

This is the #1 problem in freshman writing: students include quotes but don't analyze them.

What professors see too often:

According to Smith, "social media use has increased dramatically among teenagers" (Smith 45). This shows that social media is a big issue.

What professors want to see:

Smith notes that "social media use has increased dramatically among teenagers" (45), but this statistic alone doesn't capture the qualitative shift in how young people interact online. The increase isn't just in quantity — it reflects a fundamental change in how teenagers construct their social identities, moving from private, authentic interactions to curated public performances designed to maximize engagement metrics.

See the difference? The second version doesn't just present the evidence — it interprets it, extends it, and connects it to the argument.

3. Engagement With Complexity

High school essays often present one side of an argument. College essays need to acknowledge complexity:

• Address counterarguments (and explain why your argument is still stronger)
• Recognize nuance (not everything is black and white)
• Consider multiple perspectives
• Qualify your claims when appropriate ("in many cases" vs. "always")

This doesn't mean being wishy-washy. You still take a clear position — but you demonstrate that you've considered the full picture.

4. Original Thinking

Professors read 30-100 papers on the same topic. The papers that get A's are the ones that say something the professor hasn't read in every other paper. This doesn't mean you need a revolutionary idea — it means you need to bring your own analytical lens to the material.

Ask yourself: "What do I notice about this text/topic that others might miss?"

---

The Common Mistakes That Earn C's

Mistake 1: Summarizing Instead of Analyzing

Summary: "In this chapter, the author describes how factory conditions were dangerous and workers were exploited." Analysis: "The author's focus on sensory details — the 'acrid smoke,' 'deafening machinery,' and 'raw, blistered hands' — creates an immediacy that statistics alone cannot achieve, positioning the reader as a witness rather than a distant observer."

If you find yourself writing "The author talks about..." or "This chapter describes..." a lot, you're probably summarizing instead of analyzing.

Mistake 2: Making Broad, Unsupported Claims

Broad claim: "Society has always valued education." Specific, supported claim: "The GI Bill of 1944 marked a pivotal shift in American attitudes toward higher education, making college accessible to millions who had previously considered it out of reach."

Every significant claim needs evidence. If you can't support it, don't say it.

Mistake 3: Using the Five-Paragraph Structure

The five-paragraph essay (introduction, three body paragraphs, conclusion) is a high school scaffold. In college, your paper should have as many paragraphs as your argument needs. Some points need two paragraphs to develop. Some need half a paragraph. Let the argument determine the structure, not an arbitrary number.

Mistake 4: Weak Introductions and Conclusions

Don't start with: "Since the beginning of time..." or "In today's society..." or "Webster's dictionary defines X as..." Don't end with: Just restating your introduction or "In conclusion, as we have seen..."

Your introduction should establish the context and stake your claim. Your conclusion should reflect on the significance of your argument — what does it mean? Why does it matter?

Mistake 5: Not Proofreading

Typos, grammatical errors, and unclear sentences tell your professor you didn't put effort into the final product. Always proofread your paper before submitting. Read it out loud — your ear catches things your eyes miss.

---

How to Move From B to A

If you're consistently getting B's and want to break through to A territory:

Deepen Your Analysis

For every quote or piece of evidence, ask yourself three questions:

1. What does this evidence show?
2. Why does it matter?
3. How does it connect to my larger argument?

If you can answer all three, you're analyzing. If you can only answer the first, you're summarizing.

Use Sophisticated Sentence Structure

Vary your sentence length and structure. Mix short, punchy sentences with longer, more complex ones. Use subordinate clauses to show relationships between ideas. Read your favorite published authors and notice how they construct sentences.

Make Connections

The strongest essays connect the specific text to broader themes, other course readings, and real-world implications. Showing that you can see how ideas relate to each other demonstrates higher-order thinking.

Revise Seriously

First drafts are never A papers. The difference between a B paper and an A paper is usually revision:

1. First draft: Get your ideas down. Don't worry about perfection.
2. Structural revision: Does the argument flow logically? Are paragraphs in the right order?
3. Analysis revision: Is every claim supported? Is the analysis deep enough?
4. Sentence-level revision: Is the writing clear, concise, and polished?
5. Proofreading: Grammar, spelling, formatting.

Most students stop after step 1. A students do all five.

---

The Secret Weapon: Office Hours

College writing professors WANT you to visit office hours. Here's what happens when you go:

• They'll tell you exactly what they expect for each assignment
• They'll give you feedback on your ideas before you write
• They'll point out patterns in your writing that need work
• They'll explain their comments on previous papers
• They'll see that you're trying, which matters when grades are borderline

Bring a specific question: "I'm working on my thesis for the next paper. Here's what I have — is this specific enough?" is way better than "Can you help me with my paper?"

---

Reading Like a Writer

The best way to improve your writing is to read good writing — and pay attention to how it's made:

• Notice thesis placement. Where does the author state their argument?
• Study transitions. How do writers move between paragraphs smoothly?
• Examine evidence use. How do authors introduce, present, and analyze evidence?
• Analyze conclusions. How do strong writers end their arguments?
• Pay attention to word choice. What makes certain writing feel sophisticated?

Read your assigned readings not just for content but for craft. Notice what works and borrow those techniques.

---

Writing Process for College Papers

1. Understand the Assignment (30 minutes)

• Read the prompt twice
• Highlight key verbs (analyze, argue, compare, evaluate)
• Check the rubric
• Ask questions if anything is unclear

2. Brainstorm and Research (1-2 hours)

• Freewrite about your initial reactions
• Find and read relevant sources
• Take notes with page numbers for easy citation later
• Let your thesis emerge from your research

3. Outline (30 minutes)

• State your thesis
• List main points with supporting evidence
• Arrange in the most logical order
• Plan your introduction and conclusion

4. Draft (2-4 hours)

• Write the body first
• Don't edit while you write — just get ideas down
• Leave the introduction and conclusion for later
• Include citations as you go

5. Revise (1-2 hours)

• Check argument logic and flow
• Deepen analysis
• Cut anything that doesn't serve your thesis
• Strengthen transitions

6. Edit and Proofread (30-60 minutes)

• Read aloud for clarity
• Check grammar and mechanics
• Verify all citations
• Format according to requirements

---

How Gradily Can Help

College writing is one of those skills that improves with practice and feedback. Gradily helps you:

• Develop stronger thesis statements that are specific and arguable
• Deepen your analysis beyond summary
• Structure your arguments logically and persuasively
• Polish your writing while keeping your unique voice

Think of Gradily as a writing tutor that's available 24/7 — helping you think through your ideas and express them clearly, in your own words.

---

The A-Paper Checklist

Before you submit your next paper:

• Is my thesis specific, arguable, and analytical?
• Does every paragraph support my thesis?
• Have I analyzed evidence, not just presented it?
• Have I addressed counterarguments or complexity?
• Do my paragraphs flow logically with clear transitions?
• Does my introduction establish context and my conclusion reflect on significance?
• Have I used course-specific terminology and concepts?
• Have I revised (not just edited) at least once?
• Have I proofread for grammar, spelling, and formatting?
• Does the paper follow the assignment guidelines exactly?

College writing isn't about being a naturally gifted writer. It's about learning a specific set of skills and practicing them deliberately. Every college student can write A papers — it just takes understanding what's expected and putting in the revision work to get there.