How to Write an Essay for English Class (Step by Step)

TL;DR

Read the prompt three times, write a clear thesis, support it with evidence from the text, explain your evidence (don't just quote and move on), and proofread before submitting. The biggest mistake students make is summarizing the plot instead of analyzing it.

---

Why English Essays Feel So Hard

Math has right answers. Science has formulas. But English? English asks you to have OPINIONS about what you read and then defend them with evidence. That feels subjective, messy, and confusing.

But here's the secret: English essays DO have a formula. It's not as rigid as a math formula, but once you learn it, you can write a solid essay for any assignment your teacher throws at you.

Let's break it down.

Step 1: Read the Prompt Like Your Grade Depends on It (Because It Does)

Read the prompt three times:

1. First read: Understand what it's asking generally
2. Second read: Identify key action words (analyze, compare, argue, describe)
3. Third read: Underline or highlight specific requirements (word count, sources, format)

Common English Class Prompt Types:

Literary Analysis: "Analyze how the author uses [literary device] to convey [theme]."

• You need to: Find examples of the device, explain HOW it creates meaning

Compare and Contrast: "Compare how two texts address the theme of [topic]."

• You need to: Find similarities AND differences, analyze what they reveal

Argumentative: "Do you agree or disagree that [claim]? Support your position."

• You need to: Take a clear stance, back it up with evidence

Personal Response: "How does [text] relate to your personal experience?"

• You need to: Connect the text to your life with specific examples from both

Creative/Narrative: "Write a story or personal narrative about [topic]."

• You need to: Use storytelling techniques — show don't tell, sensory details, reflection

The type of prompt determines your approach. Misreading the prompt is the most common reason students get bad grades on essays they worked hard on.

Step 2: Gather Your Evidence Before Writing

Before you write a single word of your essay, go back to the text and find the evidence you'll use.

For Literary Analysis:

• Find 3-5 key quotes that relate to your prompt
• Write down the page number for each
• Note what literary device or technique each quote demonstrates
• Think about WHY the author made this choice

For Argumentative Essays:

• Find evidence that supports YOUR position
• Also find evidence for the opposing view (you'll address this)
• Note specific details, not vague generalizations

For Personal Narratives:

• Brainstorm specific moments (not general feelings)
• Think about sensory details (what did you see, hear, feel?)
• Identify the lesson or growth from the experience

Step 3: Write Your Thesis Statement

Your thesis is the backbone of your entire essay. Every paragraph should connect back to it.

The Thesis Formula:

[Text/topic] + [what the author does] + [what it achieves/means]

Examples by Essay Type:

Literary Analysis: "In The Great Gatsby, Fitzgerald uses the green light as a symbol of Gatsby's unreachable dreams, ultimately illustrating the impossibility of recapturing the past."

Argumentative: "While some argue that homework reinforces learning, the evidence shows that excessive homework actually harms student mental health and reduces academic motivation."

Compare/Contrast: "Although both Romeo and Juliet and West Side Story explore forbidden love, Shakespeare's play emphasizes fate while the musical highlights systemic social prejudice."

Thesis Checklist:

• Is it arguable? (Could someone disagree?)
• Is it specific? (Not too broad or vague?)
• Does it answer the prompt directly?
• Can you support it with evidence from the text?

Step 4: Write Your Body Paragraphs

Each body paragraph follows this structure:

The PEEL Method:

P - Point: State the main idea of the paragraph (topic sentence) E - Evidence: Provide a quote or specific example from the text E - Explanation: Explain how the evidence supports your point L - Link: Connect back to your thesis

The Most Common Mistake: Quote and Run

This is what students do:

"Fitzgerald writes, 'Gatsby believed in the green light, the orgastic future that year by year recedes before us.' This shows that the green light is important."

That's a quote with zero analysis. You quoted and ran away. The teacher is left thinking "okay... but HOW is it important? WHAT does it mean?"

This is what you should do:

"Fitzgerald writes, 'Gatsby believed in the green light, the orgastic future that year by year recedes before us' (180). The phrase 'year by year recedes' reveals that Gatsby's dream isn't just difficult to reach — it's actively moving AWAY from him. The harder he reaches for it, the further it slips. This mirrors the novel's larger argument that the American Dream is inherently unattainable; the pursuit itself is what defines — and destroys — people like Gatsby."

See the difference? The second version explains WHAT the evidence means and WHY it matters. That's analysis. That's what gets you the A.

How to Integrate Quotes

DON'T just drop a quote into your paragraph: ❌ "'The green light gleamed across the water.' This is about Gatsby's dream."

DO integrate quotes smoothly into your sentences: ✅ "Fitzgerald emphasizes Gatsby's longing when he describes how 'the green light gleamed across the water,' creating an image of something visible but unreachable."

Quote integration formulas:

• According to [Author], "[quote]" (page).
• [Author] argues that "[quote]" (page).
• This is evident when [Character] says, "[quote]" (page).
• As [Author] writes, "[quote]," suggesting that [your analysis] (page).

Step 5: Write Your Introduction and Conclusion

Introduction Structure:

1. Hook — An interesting opening that connects to your topic
2. Context — Brief background about the text or topic (title, author, general subject)
3. Thesis — Your argument, as the last sentence

Avoid these intro clichés:

• "Since the beginning of time..."
• "Webster's Dictionary defines [word] as..."
• "In today's society..."
• Starting with the prompt question

Conclusion Structure:

1. Restate thesis — In different words
2. Summarize key points — One sentence per body paragraph
3. Final thought — The "so what?" Why does this analysis matter?

Avoid these conclusion mistakes:

• Starting with "In conclusion" or "To sum up"
• Introducing new arguments
• Just repeating the introduction word for word
• Ending abruptly without a final thought

Step 6: Revise and Proofread

Revision (Is the content strong?)

• Does every paragraph connect to your thesis?
• Is each point supported with evidence?
• Did you EXPLAIN your evidence (not just quote it)?
• Are your paragraphs in a logical order?
• Does the essay flow smoothly (check transitions)?

Proofreading (Is the writing clean?)

• Read it out loud — you'll catch awkward sentences
• Check for comma splices, run-ons, and fragments
• Make sure all quotes have citations
• Check that you've spelled character and author names correctly
• Verify the formatting matches your teacher's requirements (MLA, double-spaced, etc.)

Common English Essay Mistakes

1. Summarizing instead of analyzing. "In chapter 3, Gatsby throws a party" is summary. "Gatsby's lavish parties serve as a facade masking his desperate loneliness" is analysis.

2. Using "I think" or "I feel" in literary analysis. Unless your teacher specifically asks for your personal response, avoid first person. Instead of "I think the green light symbolizes hope," write "The green light symbolizes hope."

3. Not citing quotes. Always include page numbers or line numbers in parentheses. No citation = potentially plagiarism.

4. Starting every paragraph with "In the text..." Vary your sentence starters. Use transitions like "Furthermore," "In contrast," "Notably," etc.

5. Writing a five-page introduction. Get to the point. Your intro should be 4-6 sentences, max.

6. Not proofreading. Spelling and grammar errors make you look careless, even if your analysis is strong.

MLA Format Quick Reference

Most English teachers use MLA format:

• Font: Times New Roman, 12pt
• Spacing: Double-spaced throughout
• Margins: 1 inch on all sides
• Header: Last name + page number in top right
• Heading: Your name, teacher's name, class, and date (top left)
• Title: Centered, no bold/italic/underline (unless it includes a book title)
• Quotes: In-text citations with author and page number: (Fitzgerald 180)
• Works Cited: Separate page at the end

Get Help With Your English Essays

English essays require both understanding the text AND expressing your analysis clearly. Gradily can help you develop your ideas, structure your arguments, and polish your writing — while keeping your authentic voice.

[Try Gradily for Free →]

---

English Essay Checklist

• Read and understood the prompt
• Found evidence from the text
• Wrote a clear, arguable thesis
• Each body paragraph has Point + Evidence + Explanation + Link
• Quotes are integrated smoothly (not just dropped in)
• Introduction has a hook, context, and thesis
• Conclusion restates thesis and answers "so what?"
• Formatted correctly (MLA or whatever your teacher requires)
• Proofread for grammar, spelling, and citations
• Read it out loud one final time

You've got the formula. Now go write that essay. 📝